When shy teen Sam (Rory Culkin) confesses to his older brother, Rocky (Trevor Morgan), that the school bully, a dyslexic boy named George (Josh Peck), beat him up, Rocky and his buddies plan the perfect payback. They ask George to accompany them on a boating expedition deep in the woods. But when their plan to humiliate George horrifically backfires, the friends make a series of poor decisions that will change their lives.